LOGICZOMBIE avatar

HOW TO SHATTER HUME'S GUILLOTINE

logiczombie

Published: 03 Sept 2021 › Updated: 03 Sept 2021HOW TO SHATTER HUME'S GUILLOTINE

HOW TO SHATTER HUME'S GUILLOTINE

(IFF) you are capable of understanding this (AND) you value your own existence (THEN) you must value the lives of at least SOME of those on which you directly and indirectly depend (humans, plants, and animals)



IF YOU SPEAK ABOUT ETHICS

then you must learn to shatter Hume's Guillotine.

Here's the short version.

There are (IS) statements.

And there are (OUGHT) statements.

An (IS) statement is an indisputable fact.

It (IS) raining.

It (IS) one hundred kilometers away.

It (IS) made of steel.

This (IS) the realm of the scientific method.

Science deals EXCLUSIVELY with the realm of the (IS).



image.png
I-MAGE



Most people think they can get an (OUGHT) from an (IS) by simply making a category-error.

For example,

MURDER (IS) EVIL (THEREFORE) ONE (OUGHT) NO MURDERY

This is a category-error because MURDER contains an implicit (OUGHT).

MURDER is generally accepted as "indisputable" (AND MISTAKEN FOR A "FACT") but this cleverly disguises the REALITY that people DISAGREE about what exactly qualifies as MURDER.

For example,

Is MURDER always "intentional" ?

And iff you believe MURDER is always "intentional" then how do you PROVE what someone was thinking at the time of the MURDER ?

ANY LEGAL SYSTEM THAT RELIES ON DIVINING THE MOTIVES AND OR INTENTIONS OF THE ACCUSED IS FUNCTIONALLY INDISTINGUISHABLE FROM WITCHCRAFT.



Leave HOW TO SHATTER HUME'S GUILLOTINE to:

Written by

welcome to thought club

Read more #ethics posts


Best Posts From LOGICZOMBIE

We have not curated any of logiczombie's posts yet. But you can encourage our curation team to review posts by visiting them regularly and by referring other readers. Because we give priority to frequently read content.

More Posts From LOGICZOMBIE