Godwin's Law.
Godwin's Law: "As an online discussion grows longer, the probability of a comparison involving Nazis or Hitler approaches 1"
Note that this is descriptive, not prescriptive. It doesn't say there's anything wrong with using a comparison to Nazis or Hitler.
So "invoking" Godwin's law as a critical response to such a comparison is not a meaningful argument.
I don't think we should make casual comparisons, of course. But I think we do ourselves a disservice if we pretend we can never compare them except in reference to themselves. Viewing them as sui generis only offers us the comfort of thinking it could never happen here. But it's far more important to recognise that it could happen anywhere, and that even if it never got as bad here - no attempt to annihilate an entire ethnic group - it could get bad enough.
And the Nazis didn't begin with concentration camps and ovens, and many joined the party and participated in attacks on "undesirables" without having an urge or an inkling that it would turn into genocide. Rather than mistakenly comparing full blown Nazi-ism with nascent violent nationalism, and reaching the obvious conclusion that they're not identical, we should look at the early moments of fascist movements, and see if our current moment looks anything like them.
Leave Godwin's Law. to:
Read more #politics posts
Best Posts From honeybee
We have not curated any of honeybee's posts yet. But you can encourage our curation team to review posts by visiting them regularly and by referring other readers. Because we give priority to frequently read content.
More Posts From honeybee
- Remember Hive!
- How well are developing nations handling the COVID outbreak?
- "We can't sacrifice lives for the economy."
- Reality vs Ideology.
- Improving the way we improve.
- Pro-life vs Pro-Choice - revisiting the moral debate.
- To live or to not die.
- Banning Chinese students is NOT the solution; open borders with incentive to stay IS.
- WHO deletes tweet about COVID-19 immunity — A few thoughts.
- A lot of folks believe government policy is keeping the economy shut down — They're wrong.