Of impulse or reason.
For me, years after having a bit of an Ayn Rand obsession, she's a perfect example of somebody who did say some brilliant, insightful things while being wrong at the very base of her philosophy.
She believed that reason should be the only guide to human action. Hume said that reason is and ought only to be a slave to the passions. It turns out that Hume was right on just about every level on that. We actually have research with people who had brain damage that hampered their ability to act on impulse. They could only act on reason. Their lives were destroyed. Imagine living a life wherein choosing between a Red Bull and a Monster is the same as choosing whether or not to bomb Afghanistan after 9/11. That's basically what these people go through several times per day. We also know that our passions come first and our reason kicks in to justify our impulses.
Rand did get a lot of stuff right. She was right about free markets. A lot of socialists might be surprised to know that she said that capitalism with government help, not socialism, was the worst of economic phenomena. I agree with her there. She said that racism is the most primitive form of collectivism in the 1950s, which was also right.
Reason does need to be a major component in our thinking; but, we're all slaves to our passions whether we like it or not. This is both an is and an ought. Hume and Haidt were and are right about how the human brain works and Rand was wrong. That doesn't make her wrong about everything. Far from it. She's just somebody who requires nuance to navigate properly.
Leave Of impulse or reason. to:
Read more #ayn posts
Best Posts From Flex Booth
We have not curated any of flexbooth's posts yet. But you can encourage our curation team to review posts by visiting them regularly and by referring other readers. Because we give priority to frequently read content.
More Posts From Flex Booth
- It's been about a year since I went down the rabbit hole of reading the works of Joseph J. Fischel.
- AI to dominate music?
- There actually isn't much of a mystery why there are so many morons condemning The Whale.
- People have shown the goodness that we're capable of in the last few hours.
- Greta has been set up for failure by the illiberal left.
- A few broader developments of the past year.
- Kamala thanks me for all I do..
- Last night I experienced racism for the first time in my life!
- I will be talking about some controversial subjects in a blunt manner.
- The "crossed state lines" talking point is so dumb that it can only be sustained in an echo chamber.
- Reading a book doesn't mean agreeing with it!
- Norwegian hate speech laws are bonkers.
- Wow. Just Wow.
- So, about Babylon.
- There's no mystery about any aspect of why hoards of people respond the way that they do to detransitioners.
- I believe that citizens of these united States should be allowed to have any weapon that the government can have.
- Jamie Lopez has died at the age of 37 and we've gotta deal with the facts of what led to this tragedy.
- The uncomfortable but necessary truth about Toni Harris.
- Is my choice to get into large format an indication that I'm throwing myself in the dick measuring contest?
- So... The Way of Water...